docs(tac): add Kelsey Hightower software factory critique

Folds Kelsey's observation that AI 'software factories' are a remix
of existing SDLC (CI/CD, compilers, gRPC, low-code) with added token
costs. Ties to MVI principle: does the AI add new capability, or just
burn tokens on work that commodity hardware already handles?
This commit is contained in:
artale 2026-07-07 15:27:23 +02:00
parent 7d0e096d61
commit e3bc60b0c9
1 changed files with 14 additions and 0 deletions

View File

@ -280,3 +280,17 @@ Reference: NVIDIA ComputeX 2026 keynote — Adel (Senior Director AI Agents) and
**ServiceNow case study:** 90% of L1 tickets resolved by autonomous agents using AIQ blueprint. System of models (frontier for orchestration, open for specialist researchers) with human-in-the-loop for escalation.
**Practical takeaway:** TAC already aligns with the system-of-models pattern (see Model routing appendix). The next step is OpenShell-style policy gating around the Hermes/OpenClaw agents in the factory — sandbox the agents that have access to internal data sources (email, forgejo, git-proxy deploy) and keep human approval on policy changes.
## Kelsey Hightower on AI software factories
Reference: Kelsey Hightower LinkedIn, July 2026.
**Core observation:** AI-powered "software factories" are a remix of the existing SDLC — CI/CD pipelines, gRPC definitions, compilers, libraries, frameworks, and low-code platforms already automate the mechanical parts of software delivery. A mature team with a dialed-in pipeline already has a software factory that lets developers focus on high-level logic.
**The MVI question for agentic factories:** does the AI agent add a *new capability* that CI/CD + compilers + low-code cannot deliver? Or is it just a more expensive (token-burning) way to do the same work — especially for parts of the process that are easily reproducible and could run on commodity hardware?
**Implications for TAC:**
- The token-cost question reinforces the Model routing appendix: route mechanical/reproducible work to cheap models or bare CI/CD pipelines, reserve frontier models for planning, design, and novel problem-solving.
- The RSI loop (cron + skill_health.py + deploy-webhook + git-proxy) already follows this pattern: the deterministic monitoring runs on commodity hardware (cron, Python), while the planning/review layer uses AI.
- Kelsey's framing aligns with the Platform Engineer skill's MVI principle: "What happens if we don't add this?" Every agent in the factory should earn its token cost vs a deterministic alternative.
- The factory inventory's 25 containers include deterministic infrastructure (prometheus, grafana, forgejo, redis) alongside AI-driven agents — the split between commodity SDLC and AI augmentation is already in place.