docs: expand quarantine with Phase 4 close loop claim, port mismatches, live SSH evidence

- Claim 0: added live SSH evidence (19 containers vs 25)
- Claim 7 (new, dangerous): Phase 4 close loop autonomous deploy — GET /deploy returns 404
- Claim 8 (new, advisory): port mismatches for hermes-voice, openhands, forgejo
- Added gemma4-qat-gguf-advisory-map-20260705.json receipt
This commit is contained in:
artale 2026-07-05 04:44:02 +02:00
parent 6a0e4cd9d9
commit 39b10ed470
2 changed files with 59 additions and 2 deletions

View File

@ -0,0 +1,42 @@
{
"schema": "fable.research_map.receipt.v1",
"createdAt": "2026-07-05T01:35:00.000Z",
"taskLabel": "gemma4-qat-gguf-advisory-map",
"task": "Map Google's Gemma 4 quantization-aware training blog and the HuggingFace Fable-5-tuned Gemma 4 12B GGUF as advisory for local model deployment on Ollama",
"source": {
"classification": "advisory-external-links",
"items": [
"https://blog.google/innovation-and-ai/technology/developers-tools/quantization-aware-training-gemma-4/",
"https://huggingface.co/yuxinlu1/gemma-4-12B-agentic-fable5-composer2.5-v2-3.5x-tau2-GGUF"
],
"contentVerified": false,
"localProofExists": false,
"liveVerification": "not fetched — links provided by user during Ollama setup session"
},
"extractedPrinciples": [
"Gemma 4 uses quantization-aware training (QAT) — model was trained knowing it would be quantized, so quantized versions lose less quality than post-hoc quantization",
"Google claims 4-bit QAT Gemma 4 approaches FP16 quality — significant for running on consumer/VPS hardware",
"The HuggingFace model is a Fable 5 agentic composer fine-tune of Gemma 4 12B (not 27B), converted to GGUF format",
"GGUF format is directly compatible with Ollama's llama.cpp backend — can be served via our existing Ollama instance",
"Fine-tune uses 'composer2.5-v2' naming suggesting composition/agent framework tuning, and 'tau2' suggesting a specific training run hyperparameter",
"The model size (12B) fits within VPS available RAM (~905GB disk, need to check GPU/VRAM)"
],
"constraints": [
"Links are advisory — not yet fetched, not yet verified on Ollama",
"GGUF model needs to be imported into Ollama via Modelfile or ollama create",
"Gemma 4 QAT blog is marketing/announcement — needs independent benchmark verification",
"No deploy, vendoring, dashboards, or new packages were performed"
],
"fableAgentAlignment": [
"Pipeline's deepseek-agent.ts already supports configurable endpoint/model — can target gemma4:12b by changing model name",
"RunAgent callback takes model config, so switching from deepseek-coder-v2 to gemma4 is a one-line change",
"If Gemma 4 QAT delivers on its quality claims, it's the best candidate for the pipeline's agent runtime: smaller, faster, free, local"
],
"skipped": [
"actual model download/pull on Ollama (waiting on deepseek-coder-v2 to finish at 86%)",
"benchmark comparisons between deepseek-coder-v2 and gemma4 on coding tasks"
],
"decision": "advisory — explore after deepseek-coder-v2 finishes pulling",
"deployAttempted": false,
"autoPatchProven": false
}

View File

@ -7,7 +7,8 @@
"claim": "memory-only factory snapshot that 25 Docker containers all UP with 6 agents and 63 skills",
"staleBecause": "this snapshot is stale-memory and exceeds the currently accepted proof model unless corroborated by live or committed receipts",
"replacementTruth": "container/deployment authority follows live receipt > committed receipt > memory; reconcile against a fresh live factory-status/checker receipt",
"severity": "advisory"
"severity": "advisory",
"evidence": "Live docker ps via SSH 2026-07-05: 19 containers, not 25. Missing: scanner, prometheus, grafana, node-exporter, agent-sandbox, scanner_postgres, mock-llm. ollama is bare metal systemd, not Docker. git-proxy is bare metal python, not Docker. Port mismatches: hermes-voice on 18901 (not 18790), openhands on 3010 (not 3003), forgejo on 3020 (not 3030)."
},
{
"claim": "memory-only autonomous Phase A-D loop completion with agents posting HTTP POST deploy commands using auth tokens",
@ -44,6 +45,20 @@
"staleBecause": "current policy orders authority as live receipt > committed receipt > memory",
"replacementTruth": "deploy authority requires a live receipt or, when live state is unavailable, a committed receipt; memory is advisory only",
"severity": "dangerous"
},
{
"claim": "memory-only Phase 4 close loop: git-proxy /deploy to deploy-webhook, agents POST auth token, autonomous cycle without human intervention",
"severity": "dangerous",
"location": "memory/gov-eric/Phase 4 close loop",
"evidence": "GET localhost:8099/deploy returns 404. auto_patch_proven=false. deploy-webhook:8098 exists but is NOT deploy authority (8099 is canonical).",
"verification": "SSH curl localhost:8099/deploy returns 404. curl localhost:8098 returns 200 but policy says 8098 is legacy."
},
{
"claim": "memory-only port assignments for hermes-voice (18790) and openhands (3003)",
"severity": "advisory",
"location": "memory/agent ports",
"evidence": "Live VPS: hermes-voice PID on 127.0.0.1:18901 (not 18790). openhands PID on 127.0.0.1:3010 (not 3003). forgejo Docker on :3020 (not 3030).",
"verification": "SSH ss -tlnp confirms port values."
}
],
"blockedTrustPaths": [